Wednesday, December 24, 2014

BitGold: The Digitalisation of Metal

Earlier this year I wrote about several attempts to back cryptocurrencies with Gold (The Truth About "Gold Backed" CryptoCurrencies). Most of those I covered weren't backed by Gold in the conventional sense (i.e. a fixed amount of Gold that could be redeemed per currency unit), instead offering only partial backing. There were exceptions such as Ripple Singapore which offers fully backed units on the Ripple network, but totals held are still very modest (not quite 53 ounces of Gold).

Since that article I've noticed new entrants being marketed in this space and interestingly two competing products appear to be jostling for the same name, BitGold.

The first of those to market comes from Bitreserve, a company offering a digital wallet service where you can transfer between Bitcoin, various currencies (USD, EUR, CNY, YEN, GBP) and now Gold (stored and audited by GBI) all through their 'card' system. Think of it like having accounts in various currencies, you can only deposit funds into their system using Bitcoin, but once deposited you can diversify that value across any of the aforementioned currencies if you don't want exposure to Bitcoin's fluctuating value. Bitreserve maintains real reserves to cover their obligations to customers which are published live on a status page.
With our Gold Card, we are reviving gold for the purchase of goods and services. Bitreserve members can convert their bitcoin to bitgold, whose value is substantiated by bullion in our reserve, but still spend it as bitcoin. By creating a bridge between the revolutionary Bitcoin protocol and good old gold bullion, we enable our members to instantly send or spend bitcoin from the ounces of gold held in their Bitreserve wallet. Our Gold Card makes this ancient store of value instantly transferable, infinitely divisible and accessible to anyone with a networked device. Now anybody with some bitcoin and a Bitreserve wallet can have the Midas touch. Old King Croesus would be chuffed. Bitreserve
They're also introducing a similarly structured card that offers their customers exposure to the oil price.
For the first time in history, oil will become a form of payment and compete against all major global fiat currencies. Using Bitreserve’s Oil Card, anyone can hold their value as oil — the fuel for the modern world economy — and transfer that value instantly and for free.

Bitoil™ will work just as bitgold does today. Oil value can instantly be converted into five currencies, gold, or bitcoin at very low cost and can be spent immediately. Oil has a massive and direct impact on the global economy, and a currency that tracks oil prices could become one of the world’s most widely used digital currencies. Whether you are a consumer looking to hold money that’s tied to gas prices, or a business with a large portion of your expenses in oil related activities, Bitreserve’s Oil Card gives you yet another welcome currency option for holding and spending digital value. Bitreserve
To be honest their system sounds quite innovative, but I am still skeptical about attempts to digitise physical assets as I will explain shortly.

The second "BitGold", is being launched early next year. The site is taking email addresses for pre-launch access at BitGold.com and they've raised C$3.5 million from investors. The founders are Roy Sebag (CEO of Natural Resource Holdings Ltd) and Josh Crumb (Former Senior Metals Analyst at Goldman Sachs).
"The Toronto-based company will allow account holders to purchase bitcoins and exchange them for gold redeemable in various vaults around the world, as well as convert the metal back into the digital currency. Customers will also get a debit card, said Sebag, 29.

The company is trying to muscle in on traditional bullion dealers and gold-backed exchange-traded funds, two of the most popular ways for retail investors to get hold of physical gold." Bloomberg
Interestingly the name that both of these new products are launching with, Bit Gold, has already been used by Nick Szabo to describe what could be considered the inspiration for Bitcoin. 
The Bit Gold proposal, by Nick Szabo, describes a system for the decentralized creation of unforgeable chains of proofs of work, with each one being attributed to its discoverer's public key, using timestamps and digital signatures. It is said that these proofs of work would have value because they would be scarce, difficult to produce, and securely stored and transferred. Bitcoin.it
His early proposal was so closely worded to the way Bitcoin works that many speculated Nick may in fact be Satoshi Nakamoto (or form part of a team that wrote the Bitcoin whitepaper).

Even ignoring the naming issue, I'm still not convinced that trying to link physical Gold with a digital representation is a good idea and here are some reasons why...

Counterparty Risk: As I said in a recent post (How Safe Are Unallocated Bullion Accounts?), I own precious metals because they have a lower level of counterparty risk, putting other parties between myself and a claim on the physical metal is counterproductive to one of the reasons I hold them. Some of these products are structured so that your claim is with the company providing the digital wallet service, while the actual custodian of the Gold may be another layer or two down. Even if regular audits occur, I would not be comfortable that my Gold would be easily retrievable if something were to go wrong (and not all are offering the ability for redemption of the Gold).

Trusted Third Party: One of the key attributes of Bitcoin and many other cryptocurrencies is the lack of need for a trusted third party to confirm the transfer of units. Transactions occur on a shared public ledger (called the block chain). With no physical asset to account for this can all occur through the use of private keys to sign transactions. The benefit of this is lower transaction costs. Introducing a physical asset to the mix means that you do need a trusted third party (sometimes multiple) to verify the assets, even if a public ledger is still used for transparency of transactions.

Spending Gold: Around 12 months ago I stumbled across a comment from Pierre Rochard talking about the consumer behaviour of those spending Bitcoin, he claimed "Consumers making payments generally replenish their bitcoin balance simultaneously, so it's a net zero." My response, why not just hold their Bitcoin balance steady and use fiat currency to make the purchase? Those introducing these digital Gold products assume there's lots of people out there who want an easier solution for 'spending' their Gold. My Gold holdings are not held for the purpose of short term spending on groceries or electrical goods, I'm not interested in giving up the security of possession for the ability to spend it more easily.

Capital Gains Tax: As I have covered on this site before, Gold (Let Australians Save in Gold Instead of Debt) and cryptocurrencies (Glenn Stevens Talks Bitcoin & Competing Currencies) are not really setup from a tax perspective to facilitate their use as a regular currency (despite the ATO recently giving a break to those using Bitcoins). It's likely that in most situations those using these digital wallet services are expected to keep records of any capital gains or losses (relative to their Australian Dollar value) to tally at the end of year for the purpose of declaring a loss or gain. The Australian tax system is not setup to cater for the use of assets (other than the Australian Dollar) as money and I suspect it would be similar in many other countries. We don't have competing currencies despite Glenn Stevens (Governor of the Reserve Bank of Australia) insistence that we do.

Government Regulation: The idea behind most cryptocurrencies is to have a distributed electronic method of creating and transferring value with no need to be in a specific physical location. Adding Gold to the mix literally destroys the advantages of a cryptocurrency because the asset it's linked to is stored centrally, leaving it vulnerable to the negative effects of government regulation.

One advocate for the mixing of these two assets has been Jan Skoyles, CEO at The Real Asset Company, whose opinion was recently covered by a Forbes contributor:
Jan’s argument therefore that there is demand for both a gold-backed currency, and a fully-transparent and accessible gold-trading system, is a persuasive one. By recording gold purchases on a block chain style ledger, the currency can be used not only as a medium of exchange, but also to facilitate gold ownership, and challenge the status quo for clearing and settlement in the gold market. In other words, you can buy your gold, and you can spend it too.
The article goes on to say that The Real Asset Company has their own product in the works. I tried to reach Jan (by email and Twitter) to confirm that's still the case and get some clarification on how it would work, but I'm yet to hear back (will update this post if I do). I'd think most Gold investors would prefer a level of privacy for their 'digital stack', something a public ledger wouldn't easily accommodate.

Everyone has different wants and needs from their assets, especially those used as a monetary resource, so perhaps there are some individuals who are prepared to look past the described shortcomings of a digitalised Gold product for the flexibility and convenience that it offers. If you are one of those people I'd love to hear your reasoning in the comments below.

Every post delivered to your inbox (free), enter your email address:


I'm sharing links and opinions daily on Twitter (@BullionBaron).


BB.


 Buy bullion online - quickly, safely and at low prices

23 comments:

  1. I'm not opposed to the idea of trying to use a digital currency backed by gold, I think it'd be preferable to fiat money. But the risk is always A) governmental takedown or B) government regulating it out of existence e.g. as you mention above with capital gains tax laws and GST and so on.


    I do think it's an interesting idea and I'm willing to see where it goes. But my guess would be that bitcoin will eventually win out for a few reasons:
    1. bitcoin can more easily be used in underground/dark markets or System D, the world's unofficial economy
    2. mathematical scarcity of bitcoin is superior to physical scarcity of gold - e.g. the "what if someday we find asteroids with massive gold deposits" argument

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks for your views. Definitely agree on point 1 (in the digital spending realm Bitcoin lends itself better to use in underground markets). On point 2, the only thing that makes Bitcoin scarce is the limits built into the protocol, to the best of my knowledge these protocols can be changed with consensus. I would suggest a change to Bitcoin's current level of "mathematical scarcity" is more likely than mining Gold from asteroids (at least in my lifetime).

    ReplyDelete
  3. @eurodrama We don't call it a currency but "shares". Could be something like #bitcoins backed by i.e. PHYS http://t.co/hJnSKfPa #Bitgold 1/2— BullionStar (@KoosJansen ) January 4, 2013

    ReplyDelete
  4. We offer fresh cut bank instrument for lease/sale, such as BG, SBLC, MTN, Bank Bonds, Bank Draft, T strips and other. Leased Instruments can be obtained at minimal expense to the borrower compared to other banking options and we also discount/monetize BG's.....
    This offer is open to both individuals and corporate bodies.
    If in need of our services, contact me for detail information.
    Thank you,

    Mr.Joe Duane
    email:jduane076@gmail.com
    Joeduane@consultant.com

    ReplyDelete
  5. We offer fresh cut bank instrument for lease/sale, such as BG, SBLC, MTN, Bank Bonds, Bank Draft, T strips and other. Leased Instruments can be obtained at minimal expense to the borrower compared to other banking options and we also discount/monetize BG's...
    This offer is open to both individuals and corporate bodies.
    If in need of our services, contact me for detail information.
    Thank you,

    Mr.Joe Duane
    email:jduane076@gmail.com
    Joeduane@consultant.com

    ReplyDelete
  6. We offer fresh cut bank instrument for lease/sale, such as BG, SBLC, MTN, Bank Bonds, Bank Draft, T strips and other. Leased Instruments can be obtained at minimal expense to the borrower compared to other banking options and we also discount/monetize BG's.
    This offer is open to both individuals and corporate bodies.
    If in need of our services, contact me for detail information.
    Thank you,

    Mr.Joe Duane..
    email:jduane076@gmail.com
    Joeduane@consultant.com

    ReplyDelete
  7. Pool Party in GurgaonJanuary 7, 2015 at 10:30 PM

    Blogging is the new poetry. I find it wonderful and amazing in many ways.

    ReplyDelete
  8. We offer fresh cut bank instrument for lease/sale, such as BG, SBLC, MTN, Bank Bonds, Bank Draft, T strips and others. Leased Instruments can be obtained at minimal

    expense to the borrower compared to other banking options. This offer is opened to both individuals and corporate bodies.

    Description of Instrument:
    1.Instrument: Bank Guarantee (BG)/SBLC
    2.Total Face Value: MINIMUM 1MILLION EURO/USD - MAXIMUM 100BILLION EURO/USD
    3.Issuing Bank: HSBC London or AA rated Bank in Western Europe or USA.
    4.Term: One Year, One Month
    5.Leasing Price: 5% of Face Value plus 0.5% Lessor agent [Closed] & X% Lessee agent (open)
    6.Delivery: SWIFT TO SWIFT
    7.Payment: WIRE TRANSFER
    8.Hard Copy: Bonded Courier within 7 banking days.

    Thank you.
    Maxie Saviel
    For further inquiries:
    Contact: Maxie.finance@gmail.com
    Skype ID: maxil.finance

    ReplyDelete
  9. I can deliver leased instruments to Organization or individuals, Trading, Discounting, signature project(s) such as Aviation, Agriculture, Petroleum, Telecommunication, construction of Dams, Bridges, Real Estate and all kind of projects with their preferred text verbiage as been approved by their bankers. We also proffer-sales option to interested buyers. Our terms and procedures are so flexible and workable by RWA clients. Our lease rate is (5.0 + 1)%+x%. X% IS Lessee broker's Commission and he determines his commission. Also we have facilities to discount BG and Put you into PPP Trading. If Interested kindly contact me bginstrumentmadate@gmail.com

    Skype : zsebe.jozsef1

    Zsebe.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Sekaran SebastianMarch 24, 2015 at 9:01 PM

    Do you need Financial Service like BG/SBLC MTN? Our Bank Instrument can be engage into Outright Discount. Feel free to write us as our terms and conditions are very reasonable. Email us so we can send you our Terms and procedure.

    Mr. Sekaran Chelliah

    bglease.sekaran@gmail.com or Skype: bglease.sekaran

    ReplyDelete
  11. Agapito Gomez MartinezApril 14, 2015 at 2:09 AM

    Dear Sir/Ma,

    We are direct provider for BG/SBLC specifically for lease, at leasing price of (5.0 + 2)% of face value, Issuance by HSBC Bank London , Barclays Bank London , Deutsche Bank, BNP Paribas, & AAA Rated Banks in Europe, Middle East or USA.

    Our BG/SBLC Financing can help you get your project funded, loan financing by providing you with yearly renewable leased bank instruments. We work directly with issuing bank lease providers, this Instrument can be monetized on your behalf for 100% funding: For further details contact us with the below information.

    Thank you.

    Agapito Gomez Martinez

    Contact: martigapito.broker@gmail.com

    Skype ID: martigapito.broker

    ReplyDelete
  12. We are direct providers of fresh cut bg, sblc, mtn, bonds and cds which we have specifically for lease. we do not have any broker chain in this offer or get involved in chauffer driven offers. you are at liberty to engage our leased instruments into trade programs as well as in other project(s) such as aviation, agriculture, petroleum, telecommunication, construction of dams, bridges and any other project(s) etc you can use these bank instruments for private placement platforms, commercial loan, business loans, credit lines and much more.

    For further details contact us with the below information....

    Contact : Mr. Petrovic Dorde

    Email: directmandate@gmail.com

    Skype ID: petrovic.dorde

    ReplyDelete
  13. We are direct providers of fresh cut bg, sblc, mtn, bonds and cds which we have specifically for lease. we do not have any broker chain in this offer or get involved in chauffer driven offers. you are at liberty to engage our leased instruments into trade programs as well as in other project(s) such as aviation, agriculture, petroleum, telecommunication, construction of dams, bridges and any other project(s) etc you can use these bank instruments for private placement platforms, commercial loan, business loans, credit lines and much more.

    For further details contact us with the below information....

    Contact : Mr. Petrovic Dorde

    Email: directmandate@gmail.com

    Skype ID: petrovic.dorde

    ReplyDelete
  14. Sunilkumar KozumalMay 6, 2015 at 1:58 AM

    We offer fresh cut bank instrument for lease/sale, such as BG, SBLC, MTN, Bank Bonds, Bank Draft, T strips and others. Leased Instruments can be obtained at minimal expense to the borrower compared to other banking options. This offer is opened to both individuals and corporate bodies.

    Description of Instrument:

    1.Instrument: Bank Guarantee (BG)/SBLC

    2.Total Face Value: MINIMUM 1MILLION EURO/USD - MAXIMUM 100BILLION EURO/USD

    3.Issuing Bank: HSBC London or AA rated Bank in Western Europe or USA.

    4.Term: One Year, One Month

    5.Leasing Price: 5% of Face Value plus 0.5% Lessor agent [Closed] & X% Lessee agent (open)

    6.Delivery: SWIFT TO SWIFT

    7.Payment: WIRE TRANSFER

    8.Hard Copy: Bonded Courier within 7 banking days.

    Thank you.

    Sunilkumar Putiyapurayil Kozumal

    For further inquiries:

    Contact: Zunilfinconsults@gmail.com

    Skype ID: zunilfinconsults

    ReplyDelete
  15. Alexander SperberJune 11, 2015 at 1:16 AM

    We have a direct genuine provider for BG/ SBLC specifically for lease, at leasing price of 5+1% of face value, Issuance by HSBC London/Hong Kong or any other AA rated Bank in Europe, Middle East or USA

    DESCRIPTION OF INSTRUMENTS:

    1. Instrument: Bank Guarantee (BG/SBLC) (Appendix A)

    2. Total Face Value: Euro/USD 1M MIN and Euro/USD 5B MAX

    3. Issuing Bank: HSBC London, Deutsche Bank Frankfurt or Any Top AA rated Bank

    4. Age: One Year, One Day

    5. Leasing Price: 5% of Face Value plus 0.5% commission fees to brokers.

    6. Delivery: SWIFT TO SWIFT.

    7. Payment: MT-103.

    8. Hard Copy: Bonded Courier within 7 banking days.

    All relevant business information will be provided upon request.

    If Interested kindly contact me via Email:~ sperblease@gmail.com Skype ID: sperblease

    ReplyDelete
  16. Dear Sir/Ma,


    We are Providers of all types of BG and MTN with the best workable procedures. Our BG ranges from MT799, MT760,(Both two way confirmation), MT103/23, MT103 (Both can be one way confirmation and two way confirmation) in USD and EUROS. Issuing Bank ranges from Top world 25 banks with face value ranging from 5M EUROS/USD to IB EUROS/USD

    BROKERS ARE WELCOME and 100% PROTECTED!!!
    Intermediaries/Consultants/Brokers are welcome to bring their clients and cases to our attention and in complete confidence we will work together for the benefits of all parties involve

    For further details contact us with the below information Thank you.


    Mr. Muhameed Liasu
    For further inquiries:
    Contact Email : muhameed.sblcbg@gmail.com
    Skype: muhameed.sblcbg2

    ReplyDelete
  17. Alexander SperberJune 22, 2015 at 1:20 AM

    We have a direct genuine provider for BG/ SBLC specifically for lease, at leasing price of 5+1% of face value, Issuance by HSBC London/Hong Kong or any other AA rated Bank in Europe, Middle East or USA

    DESCRIPTION OF INSTRUMENTS:

    1. Instrument: Bank Guarantee (BG/SBLC) (Appendix A)

    2. Total Face Value: Euro/USD 1M MIN and Euro/USD 5B MAX

    3. Issuing Bank: HSBC London, Deutsche Bank Frankfurt or Any Top AA rated Bank

    4. Age: One Year, One Day

    5. Leasing Price: 5% of Face Value plus 0.5% commission fees to brokers.

    6. Delivery: SWIFT TO SWIFT.

    7. Payment: MT-103.

    8. Hard Copy: Bonded Courier within 7 banking days.

    All relevant business information will be provided upon request.

    If Interested kindly contact me via Email:~ sperblease@gmail.com Skype ID: sperblease

    ReplyDelete
  18. We are direct providers of fresh cut bg, sblc, mtn, bonds and cds which we have specifically for lease. we do not have any broker chain in this offer or get involved in chauffer driven offers. you are at liberty to engage our leased instruments into trade programs as well as in other project(s) such as aviation, agriculture, petroleum, telecommunication, construction of dams, bridges and any other project(s) etc you can use these bank instruments for private placement platforms, commercial loan, business loans, credit lines and much more.

    For further details contact us with the below information....

    Contact : Mr. Petrovic Dorde

    Email: directmandate@gmail.com

    Skype ID: petrovic.dorde

    ReplyDelete
  19. We offer our financial instrument- lease BG/SBLC for such business covering Aviation, real estate development, oil and gas, bio tech, heavy construction involving dams, irrigation scheme, Hospitality, Foods industry, telecoms, laboratory etc.

    For further details contact us with the below information....

    Contact : Mr. Liu Xueming

    Email: lu.instrumentsprovidermandate@gmail.com

    Skype ID: liu.xueming2

    ReplyDelete
  20. We offer our financial instrument- lease BG/SBLC for such business covering Aviation, real estate development, oil and gas, bio tech, heavy construction involving dams, irrigation scheme, Hospitality,

    Foods industry, telecoms, laboratory etc.

    For further details contact us with the below information....

    Contact : Mr. Muresan Andrei

    Email: pathlease.muresan@gmail.com

    Skype ID: Muresan.Andreilease

    ReplyDelete
  21. We offer fresh cut bank instrument for lease, such as BG, SBLC, MTN, Bank Bonds, Bank Draft, T strips and others. Leased Instruments can be obtained at minimal expense to the borrower compared to other banking options. This offer is opened to both those and corporate bodies.

    We are RWA ready to close leasing with any interested client in few banking days, if interested do not hesitate to contact us via email:

    All relevant business information will be provided upon request. If Interested kindly contact me via Email:~

    Contact : Mr. Petrovic Dorde

    Email: directmandate@gmail.com

    Skype ID: petrovic.dorde

    ReplyDelete
  22. Sir,

    We can deliver Financial service/instrument(BG/SBLC/MTN/DLC/LC) at affordable price to our customers in other to derive maximum utility. We understand that finding the right company to provide financial instrument is not easy. We are certified financial company that delivers banking instrument for lease which we adhere to our terms and condition. Over 96% of our clients are satisfied with our work whether it is business or financial service.

    Once transaction is in progress, we ensure we keep you posted on the progress of your paper. We also get you connected to the provider for personalized service. Instead of stressing yourself out looking for financial instrument or company why not let professional like us deliver financial instrument to you within the time frame required by you.

    For further details contact us with the below information....

    Thank you.

    RAMESH SUBRAMANIAM IYER

    Contact: rsi.leaseconsult@gmail.com

    Skype ID: rsi.leaseconsult

    ReplyDelete
  23. Did you consider exchanging with the most recommended Bitcoin exchange service: Coinbase.

    ReplyDelete